Selected Court Cases in United States History
Commonwealth v. Hunt (1842)
1 In the 1790s workers began forming unions to bargain collectively with employers for higher wages and other benefits. Employers generally resisted these efforts. This decision, handed down by the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, strengthened the union movement by ruling that workers had the right to form a union and that doing so did not constitute a criminal conspiracy against their employer.
Muller v. Oregon (1908)
2 In the early 1900s, Progressive reformers in Oregon overcame business apposition and helped to pass a law protecting working women. The law prohibited businesses from requiring women to work for more than ten hours a day. The U.S. Supreme Court supported these Progressive reformers by declaring that the law was constitutional.
Schenck v. United States (1919)
3 After the United States entered World War I, Congress passed the Espionage Act of 1917 to punish antiwar behavior and ben antiwar materials from the mail, It also passed the Sedition Act of 1918, which outlawed speech, writing, and behavior that the government deemed dangerous to the war effort. Charles Schenck was convicted of mailing antiwar pamphlets that urged men to seek repeal of the Conscription Act. The U.S. Supreme Court upheld his conviction, ruling that the First Amendment's right to free speech did not include speech that was "a clear and present danger to the safety of the country."
Which of these pairs of cases deals with First Amendment rights?
- A. Commonwealth v. Hunt and Brown v. Board of Education
- B. Muller v. Oregon and Schenck v. United States
- C. Schenck v. United States and Engel v. Vitale
- D. Brown v. Board of Education and Engel v. Vitale
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: C
Option C features Schenck v. United States and Engel v. Vitale, both pivotal cases addressing First Amendment rights. Schenck examined free speech limitations during wartime, while Engel addressed the separation of church and state in public schools, emphasizing freedom of religion. Option A includes Commonwealth v. Hunt, focused on labor rights, and Brown v. Board of Education, which, although significant for civil rights, does not directly pertain to First Amendment issues. Option B includes Muller v. Oregon, centered on labor laws, and Schenck, which, while relevant, does not pair with a Second case addressing First Amendment rights. Option D pairs Brown v. Board of Education with Engel v. Vitale, where only Engel pertains to First Amendment issues, making it an incomplete choice.
Option C features Schenck v. United States and Engel v. Vitale, both pivotal cases addressing First Amendment rights. Schenck examined free speech limitations during wartime, while Engel addressed the separation of church and state in public schools, emphasizing freedom of religion. Option A includes Commonwealth v. Hunt, focused on labor rights, and Brown v. Board of Education, which, although significant for civil rights, does not directly pertain to First Amendment issues. Option B includes Muller v. Oregon, centered on labor laws, and Schenck, which, while relevant, does not pair with a Second case addressing First Amendment rights. Option D pairs Brown v. Board of Education with Engel v. Vitale, where only Engel pertains to First Amendment issues, making it an incomplete choice.
Other Related Questions
What was one reason for the U.S. Constitution establishing a bicameral legislature?
- A. To create checks and balances within Congress
- B. To reflect the structure of the executive and judicial branches
- C. To divide the power of initiating bills for raising revenue
- D. To allow the two dominant political parties an equal amount of influence
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: A
A bicameral legislature was established to create checks and balances within Congress, ensuring that both houses must agree on legislation, which prevents any one group from gaining excessive power. Option B is incorrect as the structure of the legislative branch does not directly mirror the executive and judicial branches; each has distinct functions. Option C is misleading; while revenue bills must originate in the House, this is not the primary reason for a bicameral system. Option D is also incorrect; the design was not specifically to balance power between political parties, but rather to enhance legislative deliberation and accountability.
A bicameral legislature was established to create checks and balances within Congress, ensuring that both houses must agree on legislation, which prevents any one group from gaining excessive power. Option B is incorrect as the structure of the legislative branch does not directly mirror the executive and judicial branches; each has distinct functions. Option C is misleading; while revenue bills must originate in the House, this is not the primary reason for a bicameral system. Option D is also incorrect; the design was not specifically to balance power between political parties, but rather to enhance legislative deliberation and accountability.
Which policy would be most effective to increase Grand Coast's comparative advantage over Toland?
- A. Raise taxes on factories and mills
- B. Encourage more workers to pursue fishing
- C. Maintain spending on infrastructure projects
- D. Improve technology used to produce timber
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: B
Encouraging more workers to pursue fishing enhances Grand Coast's comparative advantage by capitalizing on its natural resources and existing industry strengths. This shift allows for specialization, leading to increased efficiency and production in fishing, where Grand Coast may already excel compared to Toland. Raising taxes on factories and mills (A) could deter investment and reduce manufacturing output, weakening economic competitiveness. Maintaining spending on infrastructure projects (C) may improve overall economic conditions but does not directly target enhancing comparative advantage. Improving technology for timber production (D) could be beneficial but may not align with Grand Coast's most advantageous industries compared to fishing.
Encouraging more workers to pursue fishing enhances Grand Coast's comparative advantage by capitalizing on its natural resources and existing industry strengths. This shift allows for specialization, leading to increased efficiency and production in fishing, where Grand Coast may already excel compared to Toland. Raising taxes on factories and mills (A) could deter investment and reduce manufacturing output, weakening economic competitiveness. Maintaining spending on infrastructure projects (C) may improve overall economic conditions but does not directly target enhancing comparative advantage. Improving technology for timber production (D) could be beneficial but may not align with Grand Coast's most advantageous industries compared to fishing.
When is a government most likely to establish a wage floor?
- A. When wages have consistently increased over a long period of time
- B. When wages have remained constant over a long period of time
- C. When it determines wages are too low
- D. When it determines wages are too high
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: C
A wage floor, often implemented through minimum wage laws, is typically established when the government identifies that wages are too low, leading to insufficient income for workers. Option A is incorrect because a consistent increase in wages does not necessitate a wage floor; it may indicate a healthy economy. Option B is also wrong, as constant wages may not reflect a need for intervention unless they are deemed inadequate. Option D misinterprets the purpose of a wage floor; it is not set when wages are high, but rather to protect workers from unlivable pay levels. Thus, the rationale for a wage floor centers on addressing low wages.
A wage floor, often implemented through minimum wage laws, is typically established when the government identifies that wages are too low, leading to insufficient income for workers. Option A is incorrect because a consistent increase in wages does not necessitate a wage floor; it may indicate a healthy economy. Option B is also wrong, as constant wages may not reflect a need for intervention unless they are deemed inadequate. Option D misinterprets the purpose of a wage floor; it is not set when wages are high, but rather to protect workers from unlivable pay levels. Thus, the rationale for a wage floor centers on addressing low wages.
According to Cartoon 2, how were American laborers affected by foreign laborers?
- A. A larger supply of labor tends to drive down wages.
- B. A growing population tends to raise the cost of living.
- C. A growing demand for jobs tends to increase productivity.
- D. A larger labor market tends to provide better job opportunities.
Correct Answer & Rationale
Correct Answer: A
American laborers faced wage reductions due to the influx of foreign laborers, as indicated in Cartoon 2. A larger supply of labor typically leads to increased competition for jobs, resulting in lower wages for workers. Option B incorrectly suggests that a growing population raises living costs; while this can be true, it does not directly address the impact of foreign labor on American workers' wages. Option C focuses on job demand increasing productivity, which is unrelated to the effects of foreign labor on wages. Option D claims a larger labor market provides better job opportunities, but this overlooks the wage suppression effect highlighted in the cartoon.
American laborers faced wage reductions due to the influx of foreign laborers, as indicated in Cartoon 2. A larger supply of labor typically leads to increased competition for jobs, resulting in lower wages for workers. Option B incorrectly suggests that a growing population raises living costs; while this can be true, it does not directly address the impact of foreign labor on American workers' wages. Option C focuses on job demand increasing productivity, which is unrelated to the effects of foreign labor on wages. Option D claims a larger labor market provides better job opportunities, but this overlooks the wage suppression effect highlighted in the cartoon.